I got his bogo at walmart and i did buy the one in the green tube.  I am very pleasantly surprised.  I don't however like the bendyness of the applicator where it meets the brush, its "bouncey" , although the green part itself is fine. I just used my lash out brush. I got a very flirty,long, seperated look.  I curled after and then applied a light coat of waterproof and it looked amazing!  And kept the curl.  When i try that w/others the formula is too heavy and they fall after a few hours. I have tried numerous maybelline mascaras and this one is def the best!  Next time i will try the volumizing one. Even better, i have been killing my lashes for the last few years with WP and this hopefully will help them go back to the way they used to be.